First of all, this
isn’t an existentialist film by Quentin Dupieux following an implement used to
tend fires. It’s actually the first English language film from Park-Chan wook.
Wook’s films have a similar aesthetic and he doesn’t stray far from the template
that has seen him to success with his Asian films, that of the psychological
thriller mixed with an air of overall weirdness. Stoker is certainly no
exception to the rule. Wentworth Miller’s (yep, that dude from Prison Break)
script tells the tale of India Stoker (Mia Wasikowska), an 18 year old who has
recently lost her father in a traffic accident, and her relationship with her recently arrived from travelling abroad Uncle Charlie (Matthew Goode). Charlie
offers support to India and her mother (Nicole Kidman), but before long it
appears Charlie may not be the saint he’s portrayed as (especially when people
start going missing). If you know your films I expect you’re already shouting
“Shadow Of A Doubt” and you won’t be far wrong. The references are many (Miller
himself stating that his screenplay is a jumping off point from that film), but
to be fair to him his story is more centred on Charlie’s attempts to lure India
into his disturbed lifestyle as opposed to her exposing him for what he is. The
comparisons to Hitchcock have been numerous, but they don't stack up.
This moves at a glacial pace that Hitch would never have been happy with and it
completely lacks any sense of black humour that imbued even his darkest films.
Personally (the rightly revered Old Boy aside) I don’t find wook too engaging a
director. Miller’s dark narrative is a perfect match for what a Park-Chan wook
production is, but it’s too hollow and cold to really engage the audience in
the plight of the characters. However, wook is no slouch in the shock
department and the scenes of sudden violence will jolt you from your seat and
the inference of what Charlie did to his younger brother is a seriously warped
idea from Miller, nicely and subtlety executed on screen by wook. Though rough
around the edges as a debut screenplay this is a nice effort from Miller.
It’ll be interesting to see if this will be his style (i.e. minimal dialogue)
going forwards or if he’ll go behind the camera himself one day. As for wook,
this won’t be a breakout hit for him in the West, but it’ll satisfy his
followers. On the acting front Wasikowska and Kidman are quite bland (possibly
as a result of wook only being able to use an interpreter), though Goode is
great as the good looking charmer with an evil glint in his eye.
The OC Film Sting Final Verdict
I think if you’re a fan of wook already, then this is
going to be up your (blood soaked) street. However, casuals will probably want
to take a point off the score. Rating: 7/10.
No comments:
Post a Comment